“I never really know what to say when stuff like this happens, but I feel an obligation to be completely transparent with our backers.”

Eight times out of ten, a Kickstarter update that begins with such a quote usually ends up with the developers thanking the backers, and promising that their failed Kickstarter was a learning experience for the whole family, or something. One of those ten times it’ll be something nice, like “We want to be transparent with our backers, so I’ll let you know that last week the team got ice cream!”

That last time, however, is something that’s present in every American (and likely beyond) high school: drama.

ElysianShadows5

The team leader for Elysian Shadows, Falco Girgis, perhaps the greatest name of all time, posted an update outlining what happened. Girgis claims that not long after the team’s last update, way back on July 21st, lead gameplay engineer Tyler Rogers quit the team without much warning. That may sound standard; I’ve quit plenty of jobs without giving a two week notice, it happens all the time. But here’s where things get interesting.

He ripped his server out from under us,” Girgis says in the update, “took Patrick’s bed, took monitors, and took routers, without even so much as a minute’s heads up to commit code we were currently working on.

Girgis doesn’t make it entirely clear if Rogers stole this equipment or if it was his all along, but it would seem the latter is true. Girgis also goes on to say that Rogers had done very little work, and that he would “disappear for 2-3 days at a time for every day or two he worked.”

Nothing was said about the release date of the game, but it’s safe to assume the initial goal of December 2015 isn’t happening. The studio did have to completely throw away all of Tyler’s code and start anew, after all. No word yet as to how dearly the lack of a bed for Patrick is hurting the team.

ElysianShadows6

This is one of those rare times in which perhaps full transparency isn’t totally necessary. Maybe this Tyler Rogers fellow didn’t work as well as he should have. Maybe he did take his ball and go home, leaving you high and dry. But to tell us what he did, to name names, feels wrong. You could have simply left it at: “a former team-member wasn’t working out here, he took his equipment and left, and we had to start over.”

Grigis makes great pains at the beginning of the update to say he doesn’t care if he sounds unprofessional or not, which is clear throughout the post. Someone was thrown under the bus, whether he deserves it or not, in an attempt to garner sympathy for a lack of updates and a lack of progress. We have no idea what Tyler’s side of the story is, but no matter what he says, the truth will likely lie somewhere between the two.

None of it matters in the long run, because Elysian Shadows isn’t out yet, and the only five updates this year aren’t making any of the backers feel comfortable. Best of luck to them though.

Josh Griffiths

Josh Griffiths

Executive Editor
Josh Griffiths knows how to write a professional bio. He knows he should talk about how he writes about videogames and sports for a living. He also understands that he should mention that he's in charge of Cliqist's video team, and that he's got a nose for trouble. With a capital 'Q'!
Josh Griffiths

@Josh_BadWriter

Executive Editor & Video Producer for Cliqist. Writer for Twinfinite and TheGamer. Creator of @GamesofHistory_.
RT @RobForbesDJ: #DayZero scares me. Riots. Looting. Violence at collection points. Effluent rotting in the sewers since they can't be flus… - 1 day ago
Josh Griffiths
Josh@Cliqist.com
  • Falco Girgis

    Is that so? I’m sure the ten thousand subscribers we have on YouTube who have been following this project for just about a decade and who have been watching the 5+ videos we’ve released showing ourselves slaving away working on this release (which you conveniently failed to mention) definitely did appreciate it… As a matter of fact, yours is the only opinion I have even heard to the contrary. This is a very high-profile, open project, where all the fans know all of us…

  • Falco Girgis

    It wasn’t to “garner sympathy” either. It was to explain why a key member will no longer be showing up in an extremely popular YouTube series. As a matter of fact, I HAVE taken responsibility for not being able to manage him adequately and for letting someone who was clearly under qualified be on the team to begin with… I neither want nor care for your sympathy. I can sleep just fine with myself knowing that I have been transparent and honest.

  • Falco Girgis

    Also, as I had said MANY times, if he had left with an ounce of dignity and professionalism, I would not have a said a word publicly… Instead what he did was intentionally seek to sabotage something over 2k people purchased from him, like a jealous teenage girl during a childish break-up… Those people believed in him and in our dream. THAT deserves worse than being thrown under a bus.

  • Danwood

    Not releasing updates/videos does not mean no progress. I know backers want to stay updates and stuff, but as a developer myself I am much more productive when going in “hide mode”.

    • I can definitely understand that. Although, it’s understandable for backers to get skittish and even upset if there’s gaps in updates. Personally I like one update a month, and many developers funded through Kickstarter seem to deliver on that. But internally as a site we consider a span of more than 3 months without an update as MIA. Four updates a year is more than reasonable.

  • Stephen Hughes

    I can personally attest to the fact that these guys are working their asses off to get this game finished. I can’t wait for the release!!!

  • slobu

    I find that if a developer is honest I trust him more. At the same time if a journalist rehashes that drama as an opinion piece I find it unhelpful at best. The first brings clarity – the second negativity.

    • I can see what you’re saying, but I don’t disagree with James conclusion. There’s a line between being transparent and being unprofessional.

  • Pingback: Elysian Shadows Back On Track Following Team Upheaval()